The Unsweetened Tooth

Can’t choose just one? Now you don’t have to. Choose Your Two Favorites! Enjoy the best of of all of them with our Mix & Match Cookie Pack, featuring your choice of Chocolate Chip...

Bold, chewy, and full of frontier flavor—grab & go right from the pantry. Our Cowboy Cookies are a hearty, old-fashioned treat reimagined for modern, health-conscious cravings. Thick,...

30 recipes of sweet and savory dishes you can make with fruit curds. First-of-Its-Kind No Sugar Added, Gluten-free, and Keto & Diabetic-Friendly Recipes for Every Meal.

SPECIAL ORDER: Ultra-creamy, perfectly portioned, and truly unforgettable. No added sugar and 10 grams of protein. Our signature cheesecake minis are the ultimate indulgence for anyone living a...

If you’ve been craving that classic oatmeal chocolate chip comfort—warm, chewy, and loaded with chocolate—this one delivers in a big way. Our Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie is rich,...

For the peanut butter lover who’s been side-eyeing the dessert table… this is your moment. Our Peanut Butter Chunk Bliss Cookie is rich, creamy, and packed with that classic, comforting...

Soft, nutty, and packed with clean protein—snack smarter without sacrifice. Our Almond Nut Butter Cookies are a keto-friendly dream come true. Made with blanched almond flour, creamy nut...

Our #1 bestseller—and for good reason! Bright, tangy, and irresistibly smooth and creamy, this citrus-forward curd transforms everything from muffins and yogurt bowls to glazes and bars. A...

Deep, bold, and beautifully complex with a smooth, creamy finish—this rich purple curd, made with sun-ripened Pacific Northwest blackberries, is a true showstopper. Perfect in baked goods,...

Like biting into a sun-ripened peach—only smoother. This sweet, mellow curd delivers a silky texture and fresh flavor that pairs beautifully with pork, prosciutto, pancakes, or your favorite on...

Bright, smooth, and creamy, bursting with real strawberries, this luscious curd is your new everyday favorite. Swirl into pancake batter, drizzle on ice cream, or whisk into...

Discover the smooth, creamy indulgence of our four most-loved fruit curds in one irresistible gift box. Whether you’re searching for the perfect gift or want to sample our top flavors yourself,...

SPECIAL ORDER: The dessert that started it all—rich, creamy, and uncompromising. This is the cheesecake that launched The Unsweetened Tooth—our first creation, and still a customer...

SPECIAL ORDER: Pure chocolate decadence—elegantly rich and completely guilt-free. Our Flourless Chocolate Cake is a celebration of deep, bittersweet indulgence made clean. Crafted with imported...

SPECIAL ORDER: A chocolate lover’s dream—without the sugar spikes. Our Extra-Large Fudge Brownies (a full 3 oz. each!) deliver rich, indulgent flavor in every moist, melt-in-your-mouth...

SPECIAL ORDER: Decadence meets nutty indulgence—without the sugar spikes or guilt. These super fudgy brownies are a next-level treat, topped with a cloud of creamy peanut butter mousse and...

SPECIAL ORDER: Big indulgence in a perfectly portioned bite. These fudgy brownie bites are topped with a silky peanut butter mousse and finished with a layer of rich bittersweet ganache. Crafted with...